How to Create Successful Social Media Campaigns (Without Missing the Small Stuff)
Your ads are live. Your stats look good. But conversions? Not so much. It happens more often than you think and here’s why.
Most marketers track clicks and conversions and call it a day. But it’s not always that simple. Many details and behaviours don’t show up in the dashboard, and they can make or break your results.
It’s often the small details that get overlooked and ruin your social media campaign strategy and efforts. Once you get the hang of what matters, you’ll be able to optimise your campaign accordingly.
Here are some tips for social media advertising that won’t demand a bigger budget, but rather more of your patience *wink wink*.
Why Clicks Alone Don’t Measure Social Media Ad Performance
It’s easy to get lost in the stats and percentages. But, when it comes to measuring the real performance of your ads and determining if your campaign is successful, you should analyse multiple data sources.
By looking at more than one data source you will be able to understand the real performance and behaviour of the users.
For example, your Meta stats look amazing, with over 50 million users that saw your ad. Amazing, right? Wrong!
That alone doesn’t mean anything. What if users saw your ad and scrolled away, or clicked your ad, but then left without performing any other actions?
Many believe that high clicks equal high conversions. Some people click out of curiosity, not intent. Ads with lower click volume might still lead to more qualified conversions because only the interested people clicked the ad.
So, how to measure the effectiveness of a social media campaign?
To check users’ behaviour you should use other data analysis tools like Google Analytics, which breaks down user information into readable reports with multiple filters that can be applied.
By selecting the campaign period you will be able to see the bounce rate, clicks, views, and more of users who came from the social media campaign.
Don’t treat click-through rate (CTR) as your holy grail. It’s a vanity metric unless paired with real behavioural data.
Choosing the Wrong Goal
Many advertisers fall into the trap of “the more, the better” as in the more users the ads are shown to, the better results, and use Awareness or Engagement goals. That couldn’t be further from the truth.
Not knowing which goal to choose for your campaign will ruin the desired result.
If your goal is to get people on your site and get them to buy, sign up, or fill out a form, then Awareness or Engagement is the wrong objective, even if in theory, it sounds like the best option.
Why? The algorithm will analyse your target audience and show the ads to everyone, regardless of their past behaviour (if they click links, buy, etc) and even show it to users outside your target audience, who might be interested.
If you leave it on Awareness or Engagement, you’ll get views, likes, and maybe some comments, not link clicks, sign-ups, purchases, etc.
Platform-Specific Oddities
LinkedIn: Job titles aren’t always accurate as many users update their titles only occasionally. Targeting only using this option can sometimes show the ads on the wrong feeds.
Meta: Too much automation can work against you. Advantage+ and automatic placements are a great help, and in many cases, they do help, but if you’re running on a tight budget or care about who sees your ad, not just how many see it, you need to have a hands-on approach and monitor every detail of the campaign.
Landing Page Loading Speed
This is important considering today’s attention span. Most users won’t wait more than 2-3 seconds for a page to load. If users click on your ad, and you’re trying to get them on a separate page, make sure the landing page loads fast and users don’t have to wait, otherwise, you’re paying without the users visiting your services/products.
Even a 2-second load delay on a landing page kills performance, and Meta/LinkedIn won’t tell you that.
UX-Optimised Landing Page
Ensure that once the users land on the ad link, the page is optimised to show what they clicked for.
If the ad is for a specific product, ensure the product is at the top of the page.
If the ad is for a course that users can sign up for, ensure the sign-up form is at the top of the page.
Don’t make users perform too many actions in search of the service or product advertised. Otherwise, users will leave the page before performing desired actions.
Posting on Too Many/ The Wrong Platforms
Posting on too many platforms or the wrong ones can eat through your advertising budget and damage your social media campaign strategy.
Knowing who your target audience is will help you reach the right people on the right platforms.
For example, selling summer clothes is best suited for Facebook, Instagram, and TikTok as these are better for impulse buying, or entertainment.
LinkedIn, however, is better suited for professional, intent-driven ads for conferences, webinars, and B2B-focused services.
If you’re trying to reach Gen Z or younger Millennials, TikTok and Instagram are the best platforms to advertise.
For older Millennials, Gen X, and Boomers, Facebook remains dominant, especially for household items, clothing, or family-oriented products and services.
X (formerly Twitter) is strong for real-time news and opinions, but weaker for immediate-action advertising.
Treating All Social Platforms the Same
The biggest mistake when creating a social media advertising strategy is to think all social platforms have the same audience or nature.
As stated above, different platforms have different users. LinkedIn is mainly B2B and professionals, ads should be created to focus on industry services, jobs, or webinars.
Instagram and TikTok have a younger, more casual audience who are attracted to fun and trendy content.
Facebook has a mixture of millennials and Gen X, which makes it great for advertising family products and local services.
Using the same message across all platforms will miss the mark and waste the budget.
Conclusion
If you really want to create an effective social media campaign, you need to go beyond the surface.
- Choose the right goal for the outcome you want (not just “reach” or “engagement”)
- Check what happens after the click, don’t stop at CTR.
- Use Google Analytics or similar tools to track user behaviour
- Avoid relying too much on automated placements or Advantage+.
- Ensure your landing page loads fast (2–3 seconds max).
- Optimise the landing page for what the ad promises, no extra steps.
- Tailor your content and format to each platform’s audience.
- Don’t spread yourself thin across platforms, instead, focus where your audience is.
Platforms only show part of the story. The rest is up to you!
If you’re done guessing and want to improve results, let’s talk.
Check Out Our Blog!
Visit our blog for more information about the latest marketing trends and developments.
Subscribe for More Updates!
Get the latest news, tips, and insights by subscribing to our newsletter!
